Middlebury Magazine

  • Recent Stories
  • Menu
    • Features
    • Pursuits
    • Q&A
    • Editor’s Note
    • Old Chapel
    • Road Taken
    • Review
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    • How Did You Get Here Series
    • About
    • Advertising
    • Contact
    • Support
    • Writers’ Guidelines
  • Search

Fall 2019 Features

Get the Lead Out

How a Bi Hall research project resulted in safer water in Addison County schools—with further expectations to do the same for all public schools in Vermont.

By Kim Asch
Illustration by Laura Liedo
November 8, 2019
  • Facebook icon
  • Twitter icon
  • Email icon

The disturbing news flowing from Flint, Michigan, in 2015 riveted Molly Costanza-Robinson, both as a scientist and as a parent. The drinking water in Flint, a Rust Belt city fallen on hard times, had been found to contain lead. Lots of lead. In 2014, as a cost-saving measure, the city had switched to a new water source that was not properly treated with anticorrosives. Lead was leaching from pipes carrying tainted water to more than 100,000 citizens. With the water went the lead, and with the lead came the punishing health concerns that go with it.

As an environmental chemistry professor, Costanza-Robinson teaches and conducts research related to environmental pollution and environmental health. She is always on the lookout for ways to make visible to her students the invisible world of atoms and molecules. Seizing an opportunity to connect what was happening in real time in Flint to her classroom and lab, she began incorporating corrosion chemistry into her lectures and designed experiments using lead pipes with both treated and untreated water samples to see if students could reproduce the Flint results.

“I wanted my students to understand from a molecular perspective an issue that is having huge societal implications,” she says.

Costanza-Robinson was still curious. In Flint, the situation was extreme, and therefore atypical. The water’s toxicity was initially detected because of its off-color and bad taste and an increase in illnesses and issues such as hair loss and skin rashes. “Lead itself, however, cannot be seen or tasted directly, nor are its toxic effects immediately obvious,” she points out. “The quiet, incremental, and cumulative nature of lead as a neurotoxin is part of its danger.”

She wondered if lead contamination in drinking water posed a silent threat to communities much closer to home.

“There was a certain confluence of factors that were unique to Flint, but we have lead lines all over this country. We have corrosive water all over this country. We have people not funding infrastructure maintenance and improvements everywhere,” she says. “So the question became, is this also an issue in Vermont?”

Costanza-Robinson and her husband, Carl, moved to Middlebury 14 years ago and have since made strong connections in the community where they’ve raised their two children. Carl is co-owner of Frog Hollow Bikes, and the family enjoys cycling and hiking and other healthy activities the area has to offer. Both as a scientist and as a mom, Costanza-Robinson was especially interested in knowing how much lead, if any, lurked in the drinking water at local schools. She asked her contact at the Vermont Department of Health, and when she learned that the agency didn’t yet have answers, she determined that she and her students would help find them.

 

Lead is a naturally occurring metal commercially mined around the world. More than 80 percent of lead used in manufacturing goes into making batteries of all types, including automobile batteries—for both combustion engines and electric vehicles—and household batteries. The remainder is used for industrial paint pigments, roof flashing, and protecting against radiation in doctors’ and dentists’ offices, hospitals, and nuclear power plants.

When swallowed or inhaled, lead is not as benign. It can cause severe damage to the blood and kidneys and is a neurotoxin. In children, the neurotoxic effects are amplified and are known to cause behavioral problems, hearing loss, hyperactivity, and learning disabilities, and to result in a lower IQ. Children are more susceptible than adults to the effects of lead; their bodies, because they are still developing, absorb lead more readily.

Since 1978, lead has been banned in paint intended for residential use. In 1986, the federal government banned the use of lead in all plumbing parts, including pipes, solder, and fixtures. In 1995, Vermont banned lead in sinkers used for fishing lines. Also in 1995, the lead came out of gasoline.

Still, there was reason to be concerned about lead in the drinking water at schools, where children spend so many hours each week more than nine months of the year. According to a 2018 report by Vermont’s Agency of Natural Resources and Department of Health, schools throughout the U.S. have found elevated lead levels in their schools since testing began in the wake of the public-health failure in Flint. The majority of the 1,000 schools tested to date in Massachusetts had elevated lead levels, 83 percent of schools in New York City had at least one tap with elevated lead results, and 66 percent of tested Denver public schools—the majority of which were built between 1950 and 1960—had elevated lead levels

The same report points out that many Vermont schools are likely to have at least small amounts of lead in their plumbing and plumbing fixtures. Until around the 1950s, lead pipes were used for some service lines and connections that carry water from street mains to buildings. Lead-based solder used to create a watertight seal between copper pipes was outlawed in 1988 but until 2010 could still legally contain up to 8 percent lead.

“We’re above where the CDC would like the state to be in terms of the fraction of children who have elevated blood lead,” says Costanza-Robinson, adding that the numbers reduced rapidly over a 10-year period between 1996 and 2006 when a lot of work was done to ensure homes were free of lead paint. But there were still 480 children under six years old who were poisoned by lead in Vermont in 2017.

“So my question is, Is water a part of that? Typically lead paint is going to cause a much higher exposure. But your body doesn’t care where lead comes from. So if it’s coming from the water, it’s just as problematic.”

When Costanza-Robinson called her contact at the Vermont Department of Health to ask what the state knew about lead levels in the schools’ drinking water, David Grass ’99, environmental surveillance chief, didn’t have an answer. But he added that the Flint tragedy had also gotten the attention of the Health Department, the Agency of Natural Resources, and the Agency of Education, and plans were under way to conduct a joint pilot study of 16 schools in a statewide effort to assess whether lead posed a threat.

Grass, who has a doctorate in climate science from Columbia University and has guest lectured at Middlebury, was eager to bring Costanza-Robinson’s team into the collaboration: “Early conversations with Molly were, ‘OK, what’s the role for Middlebury in this project?’”

Costanza-Robinson first needed to clear her research with the Addison Central School District, which oversees nine schools in and around Middlebury. Breaking the ice was easy. The school district’s superintendent, Peter Burrows, is a personal friend.

He was initially surprised by the request. “I think everybody in the schools made an assumption that everything was fine,” Burrows says. Costanza-Robinson’s proposal to methodically test the water within all nine buildings challenged that complacency, and he immediately abandoned the assumption. “As superintendent, you want to do what’s right, do the research, and bring clarity.”

I wanted my students to understand from a molecular perspective an issue that is having huge societal implications."

 

New to the public arena, Costanza-Robinson quickly learned that while Burrows was supportive, there were other concerns that needed to be addressed. For example, how and when should the community be notified: before the testing began, or only if the results turned up problems? Grass and the Health Department provided guidance on community outreach, recommending that the district be transparent from the outset and supplying templated letters for communications.

“These are considerations that were brand-new to me,” Costanza-Robinson says.

Grass also conferred with the Robinson Lab lead team on details of their project’s design, making sure the methodology was the same so that the results would be publicly useful.

As it turned out, Grass says, the state moved more slowly, and Costanza-Robinson and her students got started first.

“The work that Middlebury did was totally their own. They took what we gave them and really ran with it. They did some excellent work and produced excellent reports that really educated all of us about what was going on,” says Grass. “They ended up being a trailblazer.”

 

The Robinson Lab lead team’s study of nine schools took time. From 2016 to 2019, six students got deeply involved during various stages as part of their course work. In addition, two classes of 27 students combined helped with a single school as part of a class project.

Their roles varied. Some developed the methods for testing with the instrumentation; others went into the schools to collect the water and analyzed the samples back at the campus lab.

It was a taxing, methodical process. Testing school drinking water requires two slightly different methods of drawing samples. Properly conducted, the test will reveal if lead levels are high and whether the lead is coming from pipes deep in the plumbing system or from the outlets that deliver the water, such as sink faucets, drinking fountains, kitchen sprayers, showers, bottle fillers, and even ice machines.

Middlebury Union High School alone had 122 water outlets. Some of the schools in the supervisory district, like Bridport, Shoreham, and Ripton, required long drives from campus in order to draw the samples. Each school had dozens of outlets that could possibly be delivering water for drinking or eating.

Water that sits in lead pipes and plumbing fixtures for longer periods of time will contain higher levels of lead. As a result, lead levels in a school’s drinking water may be particularly high after weekends and vacations. So, to get an accurate sample of the water that is typically consumed, the Robinson Lab lead team avoided collecting samples on Mondays, after holidays, or during summer vacations. Professor and students arrived around 6:30 a.m. at each of the schools in order to take the “first-draw” sample as soon as the water emerged from each outlet, and the second “flush” sample after it had run for a while. The students created detailed digital floor plans of each school, mapping the location of each outlet tested.

“Everybody had Flint on their minds, and it was really cool to look into this issue close to home,” recalls Nina Buzby ’17, an environmental chemistry major who helped launch the study for her senior research project. She remembers rising unusually early in order to get to schools before dawn to collect the first-draw sample, and how Costanza-Robinson sometimes made the earliness of the hour more palatable with a breakfast outing afterward. “Most of my interest in science is coming at it from an applied perspective. I find the public health aspect really interesting.”

As they collected data, the Robinson Lab lead team reported their results to the superintendent, facilities managers, and the state Health Department. Results were also shared widely with the Addison County Schools community via school newsletters and websites. Costanza-Robinson published reports on her website and shared them on Facebook, encouraging others to do the same. She made a presentation to the school board partway through to explain her progress and the results. The good news: there was no Flint-like problem with lead leaching from pipes deep inside the infrastructure. The bad news was that each of the nine schools had at least one outlet that delivered water with elevated lead levels. At one school, more than half its outlets were flagged as a problem. It was Mary Hogan Elementary School in Middlebury, the school Molly Costanza-Robinson’s children attended.

Throughout the process, Costanza-Robinson did her best to focus on the data and maintain her composure as an impartial scientist—despite her parental concerns. She says, “I was always questioning, making sure I was being objective, and it wasn’t just like mama bear protecting her kids.”

 

So how much lead in water is too much? It depends on who is answering the question.

The Environmental Protection Agency has set 15 parts per billion (ppb) as a regulatory lead level that water suppliers must not exceed in 90 percent of their users’ water. “It doesn’t pertain to schools per se and is not a safety level,” Costanza-Robinson points out. “It’s simply a level that, if it occurs too frequently, forces a municipal water supplier to do something to fix it.”

The health-based recommendation from the American Academy of Pediatrics is much lower: taps in schools should not exceed water lead concentrations of more than 1 ppb.

Costanza-Robinson says the lower, the better. “Most Americans have over 100 chemicals that are not intended to be in their body. Some of them aren’t doing anything. Some of them are probably carcinogenic. Some of them are probably affecting our hormones,” she says. “We know that no amount of lead in our bodies is healthy.”

The state’s pilot study mirrored the Robinson Lab lead team’s results in showing that most schools had multiple outlets with lead levels higher than 1 ppb and many had outlets with lead levels that exceeded 15 ppb. In light of these results, two Vermont state senators introduced a bill early this year requiring all schools and all childcare facilities to check their water outlets for lead and to remediate any that hit above a 3 ppb action level.

State Sen. Ruth Hardy, a Democrat who represents all of Addison County, was aware of Costanza-Robinson’s research and eager to learn more. Hardy’s husband, Jason Mittell, is a professor of film and media culture at the College, and their children are friends with Costanza-Robinson’s kids. Hardy, a member of the Senate Education Committee, didn’t take much convincing to support the bill. And because she says she wanted “to be sure that whatever we did was scientifically sound and grounded in good methodology, I felt it was really important to hear from Molly.”

In February, Costanza-Robinson went to the Statehouse in Montpelier to give testimony in support of the bill. She also enlisted the help of the state’s pediatricians and got 30 to sign on to a letter urging the state legislature to pass a 3 ppb action level. “Having an environmental chemistry professor at the Statehouse speak to the message that there’s no safe level of lead in drinking water, she was a powerful advocate to carry that message,” says David Grass of the Health Department.

Not so powerful, though, that she got everything she wanted. Legislators bumped and nudged, scraped and cajoled, and the final bill emerged with an action level of 4 parts per billion—a higher permissible level of lead than she would have liked—but also a healthy sum of money to offset the cost of replacing fixtures in schools.

“The action level we landed on is significantly lower than the federal one and the lowest in the country,” says Hardy, with a note of pride and celebration in her voice. “The bill is being touted as a national model.”

The final measure faced virtually no opposition, sailing through both houses of the General Assembly with only three nay votes. Gov. Phil Scott signed it into law in June. By the end of 2020, every school and childcare facility in the state will have submitted water for testing, which the Health Department will pay for. A searchable website is already up and running so citizens can look up test results town by town. And there is $3 million set aside to help schools pay for new fixtures where a problem is detected. (All of the schools in both the state and Robinson Lab research studies have already fixed the issues with their outlets.)

“I’m never content, but yes, I’m happy with the outcome,” says Costanza-Robinson, adding, “We’ll get it down to 1 part per billion eventually.”

Buzby, who graduated before the research project was completed, is unsurprised that her professor’s efforts have culminated in a seminal state law that will have a positive impact on the health of Vermont’s kids. “Molly is incredible. I really loved having a woman as my advisor and mentor. She is so dedicated to her students and still has time to do these research projects,” says Buzby, adding that her participation in the lead study “1,000 percent” helped land her a job at the San Francisco Estuary Institute.

The experience has crystallized Costanza-Robinson’s understanding of her role as an environmental chemist, professor, parent, and community member. “I wouldn’t say I’m looking to be an activist,” she says. “I’m looking to be useful.”

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Recent Stories

Features

View Finder

For years, photographer John Huddleston has been walking the woods near his home in Weybridge, Vermont, capturing the transitory nature of the forest with his camera. An excerpt from his latest book of photography At Home in the Northern Forest.

By John Huddleston
Photography by John Huddleston
March 12, 2021

The Man Who Saw in Technicolor

Two years after his death, remembering Jason Spindler up close.

By Ellen Halle '13
Illustration by Vanessa Lovegrove
January 29, 2021

What’s The Deal?

The story behind the critically acclaimed podcast, hosted by Middlebury Institute professor Jeffrey Lewis, that tells you everything you need to know about the Iranian nuclear deal.

By Rhianna Tyson Kreger
Photo illustration by Paul Dahm
December 16, 2020

Hunger Fight

How two Middlebury alumni are building on the local food economy to help hungry Vermonters.

By Jessie Raymond '90
Photographs courtesy ShiftMeals
December 3, 2020

Dispatches

More Than Unwelcome in America

Reflections on what it feels like to be Asian in the United States.

By Bochu Ding '21
Photograph by Getty Images
March 26, 2021

One for the History Books

Working at Middlebury for nearly 50 years, Bob Preseau had experienced just about everything that can happen on a residential campus. A retirement party on Zoom, however, was a first.

By Jessie Raymond '90
Illustration by John Dykes
March 25, 2021

Whiskey*, with a Twist

What does it mean to create a line of craft spirits that hews tightly to sustainability practices? Will Drucker '08.5 thought he'd try and find out.

By Jessie Raymond '90
Photograph courtesy Split Spirits
February 26, 2021

May I Have a Word?

During the pandemic, as the arts have struggled to stay relevant in a virtual world, one artistic director came up with a brilliant idea to showcase local talent.

By Sara Thurber Marshall
February 12, 2021

Otter Nonsense

Who had giant mutant otters on their 2020 Bingo card?

By Matt Jennings
Photograph by Daniel Houghton '04
December 17, 2020

Marble Works

How recycled stone from a College building has a second life in the local arts world.

By Jessie Raymond '90
Photograph by Todd Balfour
December 16, 2020

Home Schooled

With COVID restrictions temporarily halting normal campus activities such as in-person lectures, a pair of faculty members devised a digital alternative that should have a shelf life for years to come.

By Sara Thurber Marshall
Illustration by Harry Campbell
November 5, 2020

Home, Heart

A student-designed affordable home wins major architectural award

By Stephen Diehl
Photographs by Lindsay Selin Photography
October 8, 2020

Catching Up with Elise Morris

Our colleagues in Athletic Communications talk to the women's soccer player about one of higher education's most pressing issues: sexual assault prevention and awareness on college campuses.

By Ali Paquette
Photography by Ali Paquette
October 7, 2020
View All

Pursuits

In the Line of Fire

What it's like to be a firefighter in California, when each emergency is more extreme than the last.

By John Devine
Illustration by Stuart Biers
February 12, 2021

Q&A

On the World Stage

Only a sophomore, Nordic skier Sophia Laukli makes her World Cup debut for the U.S. National team. We catch up with her to talk about the experience.

By Matt Jennings
Photograph by NordicFocus, GMBH
February 12, 2021

Editor’s Note

A Brilliant Fogg

Saying goodbye to a dear colleague and friend.

By Matt Jennings
Illustration by Jody Hewgill
February 25, 2020

Old Chapel

The Magnitude of Systemic Racism

Acknowledging a national scourge and examining the work that must be done at Middlebury— individually and collectively—to combat it.

By Laurie L. Patton
Illustration by Montse Bernal
June 9, 2020

Road Taken

What to Wear Now

Through accrued life experiences, a writer discovers that a common question has become a statement of identity.

By Samantha Hubbard Shanley ’99
Illustration by Naomi Clarke
March 11, 2021

Quotation

A summer immersed in a language can do wonders, as veterans of Middlebury College’s famous language-learning program can attest. The lockdown is clearly going to amount to the equivalent of about two summers, and there are mini-Middleburys happening in millions of houses worldwide.”

—John McWhorter, writing “The Coronavirus Generation Will Use Language Differently” in the Atlantic.

Podcasts

Alone Together, Ep. 9 with Jessica St. Clair ’98 and Dan O’Brien ’96

Dan O'Brien ’96, a playwright and poet, and Jessica St. Clair ’98, a comedian and writer, join President Patton for our final check in with the community during COVID-19 self-isolation. Dan and Jessica are a true power couple in the arts that met in a Middlebury improv group. They discuss Dan's magazine essay "Life Shrinks: Lessons from Chemo Quarantine," how reopening the country feels a lot like remission, and how their art is evolving to reflect the pandemic.

By Middlebury Magazine Staff
June 15, 2020

Alone Together, Ep. 8 with Dick Clay, Covid-19 Survivor

In this episode, Dick Clay, a student at the Bread Loaf School of English, shares his story of recovering from COVID-19. Dick discusses when the seriousness of the virus hit him, the "wilderness path to recovery," and how he will process this experience through writing.

By Middlebury Magazine Staff
June 8, 2020

Alone Together, Ep. 7 with Jodie Keith and Jacque Bergevin, Essential Workers

In this episode, we hear from Jodie Keith and Jacque Bergevin, who have been working with custodial services to keep our Vermont campus safe and clean. Jodie and Jacque share what campus has been like since the students left: what it's like to schedule hourly sanitation of buildings, how every day feels like an empty Saturday morning, and that the infamous Middlebury squirrels have lost a bit of weight.

By Middlebury Magazine Staff
Photography by Bob Handelman
June 1, 2020

Review

Editors’ Picks for March and April

By Middlebury Magazine Staff
March 23, 2021

How Did You Get Here?

Megan Job

By Alexandra Burns '21
February 15, 2021

Leif Taranta

By Alexandra Burns '21
February 15, 2021

Mikayla Haefele

By Alexandra Burns '21
February 15, 2021

Videos

In the Blink of an Eye

Gone in less than a minute—the middle of June 2019 to the middle of June 2020, as viewed from the rooftop of the Mittelman Observatory.

By Middlebury Magazine Staff
Video by Jonathan Kemp/Mittelman Observatory
June 10, 2020

All the Feels

Current students, alumni of all ages, parents, faculty, and staff come together to sing Middlebury's alma mater "Walls of Ivy."

By Chris Spencer
May 26, 2020

A (Virtual) Visit with Kenshin Cho ’20

Laurie Patton chats with the political science major and SGA treasurer, who has been unable to return to his native Tokyo.

By Middlebury Magazine Staff
April 18, 2020
Middlebury College
  • Alumni
  • Newsroom
  • Contact Us
  • icon-instagram

The views presented are not necessarily those of the editors or the official policies of the College.

© 2021 Middlebury College Publications.