Middlebury Magazine

  • Recent Stories
  • Menu
    • Features
    • Pursuits
    • Q&A
    • Review
    • Old Chapel
    • Road Taken
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    • How Did You Get Here Series
    • About
    • Advertising
    • Contact
    • Support
    • Writers’ Guidelines
  • Search

Dispatches

The Repatriation

The Leopard Head Hip Ornament returns to Africa.

By Jessie Raymond '90
Courtesy Middlebury Museum of Art
February 16, 2023
  • Facebook icon
  • Twitter icon
  • Email icon

A stylized cat face, five inches tall and sculpted in brass, stares from a wall in the Middlebury College Museum of Art. This is the Leopard Head Hip Ornament, whose label explains that the piece was made sometime between the 16th and 19th centuries and probably once adorned the hip of a Benin Empire ruler’s costume. The ornament was stolen after the disturbingly named Benin Punitive Expedition in 1897, when British forces destroyed a Benin palace in present-day Nigeria and took thousands of objects, collectively known as the Benin treasures. Some of the looted pieces, like this one, were handed out to expedition leaders as souvenirs; others went to the British Museum and other institutions.

Richard Saunders, the museum’s director, purchased the piece in 1997, seeing its violent backstory as part of its value as a teaching tool. “The way we’ve used this piece at Middlebury is not to hide its history but to basically raise the question ‘Do we have rightful ownership of this?’” he says. It is the sort of academic discussion a museum, especially one at an institution of higher learning, welcomes. But it’s also one that has, in recent years, prompted museums around the world to reassess the objects in their collections and, where appropriate and possible, take steps to return stolen objects to their rightful heirs.

Saunders could see, in the face of growing cultural sensitivity, that the museum’s possession of the leopard ornament was becoming problematic. “It finally came to a head in 2019–2020, when we were publishing the handbook of our collection, and the copy editor said, ‘Richard, you say in this entry that this is stolen. Why would you want to have a stolen object in your handbook?’” He had no good answer. He reached out to Middlebury president Laurie Patton to explain his feeling that the time had come to return the ornament to Nigeria. With her approval, he met online with a representative of the Legacy Restoration Trust, a Nigerian nonprofit, to initiate the process of repatriation.

The trend of returning stolen antiquities is, Saunders says, “the result of an increasing awareness of colonialism and the fact that certain countries around the world have had the power and the privilege to control things and own things. And now that’s no longer seen as something that is completely acceptable in the old form.” He admits this was not always the case. “I’m sure that when I first walked into the British Museum or the Met and looked at things that were on view, I didn’t think twice about how those objects got there.”

Times have changed. A December 2022 article in the New York Times calls the current spike in repatriation a sign that “the Indiana Jones era is over.” A May 2022 article in the Washington Post (in which Saunders is quoted) explores how the Benin treasures are currently a major focus for institutions all over the world. So many places are trying to return looted objects that the Nigerian government is struggling to keep up with all the requests.

FINDERS, NOT KEEPERS?

Though the leopard-head hip ornament is the only object in the museum’s collection that can clearly be documented to have been stolen, Saunders points out various antiquities whose rightful heirs could be debated—a two-foot-tall warrior sculpture from the Congo, a Chinese porcelain excavated off the coast of Vietnam. He explains that provenances of antiquities rarely go back far enough to tell their original stories. An object may have been stolen or it may have been sold or given as a formal gift. And even if an ancient artifact is proven to have been taken illegally, how can it be returned to its owners if the country’s borders, and even the culture, no longer exist? What about items that are lost—and later found—at sea?

As an example, Saunders brings me to a 90-by-94-inch Assyrian alabaster relief, Winged Genie Pollinating the Date Palm, mounted in the entry of the museum. It was the first alumni gift to the museum, given by the Reverend Wilson Farnsworth, Class of 1848. Dozens of related reliefs, excavated from the same ancient palace site in what is now Iraq, are housed all over the world. Given that the reliefs are over 2,000 years old, it would be difficult, Saunders says, to determine who owns them today. “And who would you return them to? You could return them to the Iraqi government, but when ISIS controlled that area of Iraq, they bulldozed what remained of the palace.”

RETURN POLICY

For the time being, the Leopard Head Hip Ornament will remain at the Museum of Art. While there are plans for a new museum in Benin City—designed by renowned Ghanaian-British architect Sir David Adjaye—to house the thousands of objects that are being returned from around the world, completion is years away. Construction won’t begin until the British Museum finishes conducting archaeological work on the site of the old royal palace, on which the Edo Museum of West African Art will eventually be built.

Saunders isn’t sure yet how repatriation of the leopard head will be handled. “We could have a formal transfer to the Nigerian authorities before then, so the museum plaque would say it is owned by either the Legacy Restoration Trust or another Nigerian body. But it would stay on view here until this new museum exists.” He’s happy for it to spend a few more years at our museum; its presence tells a story about colonialism that, however dark, should be told.

The repatriation of the Leopard Head Hip Ornament is the result of a growing conversation about what objects come into a museum’s collection and how—and even whether—they should be displayed. While Saunders calls these issues “complex,” he says a museum, particularly one at a teaching institution, must be open to that conversation. “What’s important is the dialogue.”

As for the responsibility of a museum director in the face of rapidly changing attitudes, he says, “All you can do is try to be responsible and ethical and do your best and admit when you’ve made a mistake.”

 

Leopard Head Hip Ornament, Nigeria, Benin Kingdom, Edo peoples, 16th–19th century, Brass, 5-1/4 x 4 x 2 Purchase with funds provided by the Christian A. Johnson Memorial Art Acquisition Fund, 1997.020

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Recent Stories

Features

More Than a Game

In a critically acclaimed work of nonfiction, Abe Streep '04 introduces readers to the Arlee Warriors, a high school basketball team on a Native American reservation in Montana, where life's challenges are abundant.

By Alexander Wolff
Photograph by Devin Yalkin
October 21, 2022

Munya Munyati Has A Few Stories to Tell

Catching up with a young filmmaker who is rapidly making a name for himself at Vice.

By Mara Dolan
Film stills by Munya Munyati
September 16, 2022

Reverberations

A transcontinental move, a career discovered, a landmark speech studied and translated—and an identity reshaped.

By Clara Clymer, MA Translation '22
Illustration by Anna Gusella
April 2, 2022

The Road(s)

A little over a year ago, a writing student headed south to Florida for no other reason than J-Term was forced to go remote. She soon found herself reporting on an environmental justice battle that was roiling the state.

By Alexandra Burns '21.5
Illustrations by Yevgenia Nayberg
March 2, 2022

Dispatches

The Repatriation

The Leopard Head Hip Ornament returns to Africa.

By Jessie Raymond '90
Courtesy Middlebury Museum of Art
February 16, 2023

Adventures in Filmmaking

Two professors and an alum have embarked on a journey to take a screenplay from its creation to the end product of a full-length feature film.

By Sara Thurber Marshall
Still Photograph from The Swim Lesson Proof of Concept
February 14, 2023

A Night Out

For one evening in December, Atwater dining hall hosted a student-dining experience unlike any other.

By Caroline Crawford
Photographs by Paul Dahm
January 20, 2023

Finding His Way

What happens when your identity is stolen—not by another person but by your own body?

By Sara Thurber Marshall
December 15, 2022

A Natural Selection

For more than a quarter century, Stephen Trombulak— now an emeritus professor of biology and environmental studies—guided students in avian research on a parcel of College land hard by Otter Creek. This preserved area now bears his name.

By Jessie Raymond '90
Photography by Paul Dahm
November 18, 2022

The Utterly Fascinating Life of Howie McCausland

He saves lives. He brought the Internet to Middlebury. He has a degree in astrophysics. And he loves to fish. Yes, this is a true story.

By Jessie Raymond '90
Illustration by John S. Dykes
September 16, 2022

It’s a New Day at the Museum of Art

Reimagining what an art museum can and should be.

By Jessie Raymond '90
Art courtesy of the Middlebury College Museum of Art
June 30, 2022

First Aid

Their projects span the globe—from Kenya to Haiti to the United States. As the 2021-22 academic year came to a close, a cohort of students gathered to discuss what having a social impact really means.

By Sara Thurber Marshall
Illustration by Brian Stauffer
June 28, 2022

The Case of the Purloined Onions

Onions have been disappearing from Middlebury's garden. Now, a team of undergraduate sleuths are honing in on a lineup of suspects.

By Andrew Cassel
Illustration by Naomi Ann Clarke
June 21, 2022
View All

Pursuits

Public Defender

On becoming one of the country's foremost cybersecurity experts.

By Jessie Raymond '90
Illustration by Neil Webb
April 14, 2022

Q&A

The Making of a Teacher

Hebrew Professor Michal Strier reflects on her life an education—in Israel and the States—a journey that led the Language School instructor to the undergraduate College for the first time this year.

By Jessie Raymond '90
Photograph by Paul Dahm
May 19, 2022

Editor’s Note

A Brilliant Fogg

Saying goodbye to a dear colleague and friend.

By Matt Jennings
Illustration by Jody Hewgill
February 25, 2020

Old Chapel

Making Democracy Real

An Update on Our Conflict Transformation Initiative

By Laurie L. Patton
Illustration by Montse Bernal
January 20, 2023

Road Taken

What to Wear Now

Through accrued life experiences, a writer discovers that a common question has become a statement of identity.

By Samantha Hubbard Shanley ’99
Illustration by Naomi Clarke
March 11, 2021

Quotation

A summer immersed in a language can do wonders, as veterans of Middlebury College’s famous language-learning program can attest. The lockdown is clearly going to amount to the equivalent of about two summers, and there are mini-Middleburys happening in millions of houses worldwide.”

—John McWhorter, writing “The Coronavirus Generation Will Use Language Differently” in the Atlantic.

Podcasts

Introducing Midd Moment: Season 3

Coming this spring, season three of Midd Moment.

By Middlebury Magazine Staff
March 31, 2023

Alone Together, Ep. 9 with Jessica St. Clair ’98 and Dan O’Brien ’96

Dan O'Brien ’96, a playwright and poet, and Jessica St. Clair ’98, a comedian and writer, join President Patton for our final check in with the community during COVID-19 self-isolation. Dan and Jessica are a true power couple in the arts that met in a Middlebury improv group. They discuss Dan's magazine essay "Life Shrinks: Lessons from Chemo Quarantine," how reopening the country feels a lot like remission, and how their art is evolving to reflect the pandemic.

By Middlebury Magazine Staff
June 15, 2020

Alone Together, Ep. 8 with Dick Clay, Covid-19 Survivor

In this episode, Dick Clay, a student at the Bread Loaf School of English, shares his story of recovering from COVID-19. Dick discusses when the seriousness of the virus hit him, the "wilderness path to recovery," and how he will process this experience through writing.

By Middlebury Magazine Staff
June 8, 2020

Review

Heart and Soul(s)

Funny and touching, this story centers on a small town and the escapades of its inhabitants—both living and dead.

By Sara Thurber Marshall
Illustration by Miki Lowe
March 29, 2023

How Did You Get Here?

Megan Job

By Alexandra Burns '21
February 15, 2021

Leif Taranta

By Alexandra Burns '21
February 15, 2021

Mikayla Haefele

By Alexandra Burns '21
February 15, 2021

Videos

Pomp and Unusual Circumstances

As viewed from above.

By Chris Spencer
June 1, 2021

Davis the Owl Returns Home

Having recovered from life-threatening injuries, a beautiful winged creature is released to its natural habitat.

By Andrew Cassell
April 22, 2021

In the Blink of an Eye

Gone in less than a minute—the middle of June 2019 to the middle of June 2020, as viewed from the rooftop of the Mittelman Observatory.

By Middlebury Magazine Staff
Video by Jonathan Kemp/Mittelman Observatory
June 10, 2020
Middlebury College
  • Alumni
  • Newsroom
  • Contact Us
  • icon-instagram

The views presented are not necessarily those of the editors or the official policies of the College.

© 2023 Middlebury College Publications.